5 WAYS EMPLOYERS SCREEN OUT THE BEST CANDIDATE

Jeff Mignault • June 27, 2017

We all want to hire the best candidate. However, separating the best candidate from the crowd is challenging. With so many applicants, and some very similar, it is tough to distinguish between them.

EFFECTIVE WAYS TO SCREEN FOR THE BEST CANDIDATE

Here are some strategies to use to identify and separate the best candidates from the pool of applicants:

1. REFRESH SCREENING CRITERIA:

If your organization has been having difficulty finding the best candidates, then perhaps it’s time to refresh your approach in how you attempt to identify the best candidates. This could mean refreshing job descriptions, interview questions and how you check references.

2. JOB ADS:

If you have poor job ads, then you will attract a poor pool of candidates. Finding the best candidates starts with writing an engaging and specific job description that explains exactly what you are seeking and what the role entails. Be direct and to the point.

3. ASK THE RIGHT QUESTIONS:

A canned selection of generic interview questions will not do most candidates any justice. If you want to find the best candidate, then you need to ask challenging questions. “The only thing that limits a company from finding the right fit is having a management team that is afraid to ask candidates to validate their own experiences. People can say anything; however, it’s the people who execute who rise above. Whether the interview is in person, via email or on a video call, ask people to demonstrate their accomplishments and make objective decisions based on their results,” says Tom Gimbel on Entrepreneur.

4. USE A COMBINATION OF STRATEGIES:

There is no one perfect screening strategy that will help you identify the best candidate. Every job and hiring process is unique. While using keyword algorithms to screen resumes can provide you with some good information, it’s not a replacement for reviewing resumes, or having a phone or video interview. Use all the resources you have to make the most informed and educated decision possible.

5. WORK WITH AN HR RECRUITER:

Sometimes you need to go outside of the organization if you want to improve your recruiting efforts. Working with an HR recruiter can provide you with some key insights into hiring best practices and help you improve your approach to hiring. Plus, a fresh set of eyes can help identify potential issues preventing you from finding the best candidates.

MORE HR RECRUITING TIPS

Jeff Mignault
HR professional shaking hands with candidate, representing outsourced HR and business growth success
April 22, 2026
Discover how outsourced HR reduces overhead, lowers turnover costs, and drives measurable ROI. Learn how flexible HR models improve growth, compliance, and performance.
Manager discussing a workplace issue with an employee, representing a common leadership challenge.
April 15, 2026
Discover the 8 most common management mistakes new leaders make and how to avoid them. Improve delegation, feedback, onboarding, compliance, and team results.
Professional woman at laptop rubbing eyes, representing workplace stress and HR decision challenges.
April 1, 2026
Learn the signs you may be overpaying or underpaying employees and how salary benchmarking helps build a competitive, equitable compensation strategy.
HR discussion between two employees, representing workplace conflict and employee relations issues
March 25, 2026
Discover the hidden costs of DIY HR, including legal risks, lost productivity, and employee turnover, and when to outsource HR support for your business.
Man typing on a computer while using calculator representing payroll processing, financial analysis
March 18, 2026
Learn the most common payroll compliance mistakes Canadian employers make, potential CRA penalties, and practical steps to keep your payroll processes compliant.
Two women professionals reviewing salary documents and compensation reports together
March 4, 2026
Learn how often to update salary bands, the risks of outdated pay ranges, and best practices for benchmarking compensation in Canada.
Tense HR compliance meeting between three professionals in an office
February 25, 2026
Discover the top HR compliance risks Canadian employers face, including termination, misclassification, and employment law violations—plus how to mitigate them.
Two men argue while a woman stands between them, trying to mediate a workplace conflict
February 11, 2026
Learn the difference between workplace conflict and harassment in Canada, including legal definitions, real examples, and when employers must intervene.
Photo showing the difference between an independent contractor and an employee in Canada
February 4, 2026
Learn the difference between an independent contractor and an employee in Canada, how CRA determines status, and the risks of misclassification.
HR consultant coaching Gen Z employees on communication and people skills in the workplace
January 28, 2026
Learn why Gen Z struggles with people skills at work and how HR leaders can train communication, teamwork, and emotional intelligence effectively.