6 COSTLY MISTAKES MOST PEOPLE MAKE WHEN RECRUITING

Jeff Mignault • June 22, 2017

Recruiting is your opportunity to find the best talent available and improve your company. However, if you don’t take it seriously or have a poor recruiting process, you could find yourself recruiting again in the short term because of a bad hire.

6 COSTLY MISTAKES MOST PEOPLE MAKE WHEN RECRUITING

1. NOT KNOWING WHO YOU ARE LOOKING FOR:

Successful recruiters know what they are looking for. Therefore, it’s essential that you have an ideal candidate profile. You can use this as the basis to qualify candidates and use it as a checklist to compare candidates.

2. MAKING ASSUMPTIONS:

Never make assumptions about candidates or how they will act/react during the hiring process. Don’t assume you have found the perfect candidate; or once interviews are complete, don’t assume a candidate is going to accept your job offer. Nothing is certain until a candidate signs the employment contract.

3. WRITING POOR JOB ADS:

If you write poor job ads, then you will likely attract a poor pool of candidates. Too many companies simply recycle old job ads and don’t invest the time or effort into writing detailed and enticing job ads. If you want to attract good talent, you need to write great ads.

4. NOT OPERATING WITH A SENSE OF URGENCY:

People don’t like to wait, and candidates won’t wait around forever to hear back from you. In fact, if you don’t act right away when you identify a top talent, you risk losing them to a competitor. If you’ve identified a candidate as a great talent, so have other companies. If you wait too long, candidates will move on and you’ll miss out.

5. NOT INVESTING IN THE PROCESS:

Recruiting is one of the most important processes for your organization. Failure to invest in the process will put your company at a disadvantage when it comes time to hire. Talent is a core resource, and if you can’t attract top talent, your company will suffer.

6. NOT DOING A BACKGROUND CHECK:

Always check references and look into a candidate more thoroughly post-interview. Hiring is an important decision. You are investing in a person, and you need to perform your due diligence to make sure you are making the correct decision.

MORE RECRUITING TIPS

Check out these insightful recruitment tips to improve your hiring success:

Jeff Mignault
Man typing on a computer while using calculator representing payroll processing, financial analysis
March 18, 2026
Learn the most common payroll compliance mistakes Canadian employers make, potential CRA penalties, and practical steps to keep your payroll processes compliant.
Two women professionals reviewing salary documents and compensation reports together
March 4, 2026
Learn how often to update salary bands, the risks of outdated pay ranges, and best practices for benchmarking compensation in Canada.
Tense HR compliance meeting between three professionals in an office
February 25, 2026
Discover the top HR compliance risks Canadian employers face, including termination, misclassification, and employment law violations—plus how to mitigate them.
Two men argue while a woman stands between them, trying to mediate a workplace conflict
February 11, 2026
Learn the difference between workplace conflict and harassment in Canada, including legal definitions, real examples, and when employers must intervene.
Photo showing the difference between an independent contractor and an employee in Canada
February 4, 2026
Learn the difference between an independent contractor and an employee in Canada, how CRA determines status, and the risks of misclassification.
HR consultant coaching Gen Z employees on communication and people skills in the workplace
January 28, 2026
Learn why Gen Z struggles with people skills at work and how HR leaders can train communication, teamwork, and emotional intelligence effectively.
Woman in front male coworkers in the background appear to gossip, illustrating workplace harassment
January 21, 2026
Learn when to start a workplace harassment investigation, how investigations work in Canada, standards of proof, and what employers must not say.
Employee working with vacation gear at the office, illustrating vacation accrual and carryover rules
January 14, 2026
Learn how vacation accrual and carryover works in Canada. Compare provincial rules, use-it-or-lose-it policies, payouts, and employee entitlements.
Burned-out match representing employee burnout in the workplace
December 17, 2025
Learn the top signs of employee burnout and practical remedies employers can use to reduce stress, improve morale, and build a healthier, more productive workplace.
HR team reviewing January 2026 pay equity and transparency compliance checklist
December 8, 2025
Prepare for Ontario’s January 1, 2026 pay equity and transparency rules. Learn what’s changing, compliance steps, risks of non-compliance, and how HR can get ready.